Posts

🟥 Rabindranath Tagore and His Understanding of Nationalism | Sowmen Mitter

Image
🟦 Rabindranath Tagore’s understanding of nationalism is one of the most intellectually complex and important aspects of his thought. He was deeply involved in the political and cultural life of colonial India, participated in the Swadeshi movement, wrote patriotic songs, supported indigenous industry and education, and eventually renounced his knighthood after the Jallianwala Bagh massacre. Yet Tagore became increasingly critical of nationalism when it developed into an ideology of collective pride, political domination, exclusion and mechanical organisation. His position was therefore neither a simple rejection of patriotism nor an acceptance of nationalism in its European, state-centred form. Rather, he sought to place the love of one’s country within a larger ethical commitment to humanity. This distinction is essential for understanding works such as Nationalism, Gora, The Home and the World (Ghare-Baire), Swadeshi Samaj, and several of his poems and essays. Tagore’s p...
Post a Comment
Read more

Cassius’s Foresightedness Could Have Proved an Asset for Them but for the Idealistic Idiocy of Brutus (In the Light of Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar | Sowmen Mitter

Image
🟥 Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar presents a tragedy of political idealism colliding with pragmatic realism. The conspiracy against Caesar succeeds in the act of assassination but collapses in its aftermath. At the heart of this collapse lies the contrast between Cassius’s shrewd foresight and Brutus’s rigid, idealistic honour. Cassius repeatedly anticipates dangers and proposes practical countermeasures; Brutus repeatedly overrides those measures with lofty principles that prove disastrous. The essay argues, point by point, that Cassius’s foresight could have secured the conspirators’ position, but Brutus’s idealistic idiocy systematically nullified that advantage. 1. Cassius’s Early Perception of Caesar’s Ambition and the Necessity of Brutus   Cassius is the first to recognise that Caesar’s growing power threatens the Republic. In Act I, Scene ii, he delivers the famous “lean and hungry” speech, recalling how he once saved Caesar from drowning and how Caesar cried “...
Post a Comment
Read more

Happy Daughter's Day | Sowmen Mitter

Image
My Dearest Sanjhbati , Though this wish comes a little later than Daughter's Day, I hope you will accept it with the same warmth and love with which it is written. Love does not keep a calendar; it simply finds its way to the people who matter most. Watching you grow from a little child into a thoughtful adolescent has been one of the greatest joys of my life. Every stage of your journey has taught me something about hope, courage, and the beauty of becoming your own person. You are no longer the tiny hand I once held all the time, but you will always be the little girl who holds a permanent place in my heart. As you step into the exciting and sometimes confusing years of adolescence, remember that you do not have to be perfect. You only have to be honest, kind, and true to yourself. There will be days when life feels difficult, when you may doubt your abilities or feel misunderstood. On those days, never forget that your family believes in you, and I believe in you more than words...
Post a Comment
Read more

Compensating a grieving mother? | Sowmen Mitter

Image
It's the new normal now. Once you have a son, or a daughter, or a brother killed, you get to become an MLA, courtesy of the ruling party or the party that's likely to grab power. The trend was set by Mamata Banerjee whose insatiable lust for power set such a kind of series of precedents as can only be matched by a prodigal son who is already known by the very vile company he keeps. Nobody will ever know which circumstances allegedly led to Rizwanur Rahman dying by suicide, even though that's precisely what his elder brother Rukbanur and the TMC, which fielded him as a candidate, capitalised on to evoke the sympathy of the electorate and thereby, secure the mandate.  Then, came Mrs Debnath, who is still, and continually, clamouring for justice for her slain daughter, but in vain. Politically naive as she is, she is yet to realise that she must keep mum. Maybe, a few 'snubs' would do that, and I'm afraid she's already got the necessary 'hint'.  And now...
Post a Comment
Read more

For whom the bell tolls?

Image
This was but expected. This is perhaps, provided the report is authentic, the first ever toll of the politically motivated exercise about to be launched in a few days' time. As I hear, from the 4th of November onwards.... And I'll not be surprised if many more such people succumb to their anxieties as a result of this. This can also assume very sinister proportions unless otherwise checked in a sane manner. In a country like ours where so many people, particularly those living on the margins, do not have access to proper documents, this entire thing called the Special Intensive Revision might prove to be a Damocles' sword for the powers that be.  But then the dispensation at the centre is confident. With the tens of thousands of their IT cell trolls and the subservient godi media across the country, they know they can help themselves tide over any such imminent crises like they did during those Covid times as well when no deaths nor anything could deal the desired blow to t...
Post a Comment
Read more

Don't interfere with our food habits

Image
You may call me a provincial chauvinist or whatever; but these scoundrels, and the party at whose behest they dare do this need to be dealt with properly. I'm not here to promote parochial identity-politics (which I'm severely opposed to as a matter of principle); but then, I'm afraid that if such aggressive overtures are allowed to go on like this for long, there will soon come a time when us Bengalis would have to live in perpetual fear of them, haunted by a sense of total insecurity in our own homeland. Such incidents appear to be gradually and steadily on the rise; and can no longer be ignored or wished away as just occasional instances of aberration. We must rise to the occasion ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Ravens scavenging for carrion flesh..

Image
Circa 2009/10. Yes, these intelligent scoundrels exercised their democratic rights that day by aiding and abetting the terror machine that left hundreds of socially marginalized Left activists gruesomely mutilated and killed, many of whose corpses were left to rot for days on end without being attended to for a dignified farewell.  Yes, these self-important members of the so-called civil society were certainly decisive in their posturing at that time, and later, effusive in celebrating and presiding over the decimation or "demise" of the Left in Bengal. In collusion with the deep state and vested interests of all sorts and hues - ranging from the saffron or ochre to the deep "revolutionary" scarlet red! 😀  And now, when one of these clever ravens - known for his freewheeling 'conscience-keeping' - is again opening up to state who is "confused" - u know he is again out to scavenge for carrion flesh. Yes, my use of the phrase is deliberate. Corpses...
Post a Comment
Read more